This is the time of year where I start my daily affirmations of "Tanning beds are bad. Do not go to the tanning bed."
I'm a recovered tanning bed
Okay, stepping off my PSA soapbox. Anyway, I've tried several self tanners recently and thought I'd tell you what I think about them. Also I'm trying to get my booty on my blog more, so thought this was a good opportunity to ramble and review all at once.
![]() |
| Buy it here |
Pros
- Works quickly
- Looks natural
- Isn't super pricey
- Everyone carries it- Ulta, Target, drugstores. That's a bonus if you ask me. Easy access...haha...:)
- If you exfoliate first and moisturize, the tan lasts quite awhile for a lotion. I'll apply it like three days in a row and then not apply for the next 4 or 5 days and still have good color.
Cons
- Smells like burnt fritos (that's what I think self tanners smell like)
- Bottle doesn't last a long time
![]() |
| Buy it here |
Pros
- SO EASY
- Not messy at all
- Faint smell
- Good color
- One cloth really does cover your whole body
- Don't get that sticky feel you get from a lotion.
Cons
- Can't really see where it's going on as you wipe it on. Color develops later. (But I should note that it still didn't dry streaky. I just like to see where it's going, that's all).
- Kind of pricey. I mean, at $5/towel for one tan application vs $7.99 or whatever for the Jergens that gives you multiple applications...eh.. But the multipack IS a good deal, especially on Amazon.
![]() |
| Buy it here. |
On my first application, I was hesitant and didn't apply that much. I got in the shower the next day and watched my tan wash down the drain. :( I had color, but I definitely could have applied more. So, that's what I did the next time. It gives you that false color...like when you spray tan...so you think you're tanner than you are. But, then after sleeping overnight and showering or whatever, it looks really natural! On me, it looks kinda like a level one spray tan...or maybe even a tinge darker...but definitely not level two...after two applications. (Remember, my first application was super light b/c I was nervous).
Overall, this one is my favorite for right now and I'm going to stick with it. Plus, I feel like my two applications barely made a DENT in the bottle. This will last a long time! YAY! I will, however, need Eric to spray my back and use the mitt to rub it in. (Oh the joys he gets to deal with living with me). Let me say.. I haven't let this fade yet. So I could come back next week with blotches and craziness and totally take all this back...haha.. But for now, I am totally blown away by how much I like this product.
Pros
- Cost effective (Even if you buy it at Ulta or somewhere not as cheap as Amazon, I can tell it lasts a long time, so that makes it awesome!)
- Great color!
- No streaking...seriously...even less streaking than with any lotion I've tried.
- Easy as heck.
- Immediate color. Since it gives you that "false" spray tan color while it develops, you could easily spray this and go out for the night with a tan.
- Pleasant smell...compared to the others I've tried that smell like stale or burnt fritos. *blech* And the smell is tropical/strong at first but after your shower, you really can't even smell it. I don't feel that way about the lotions.
Cons
- Is definitely messier than the Tan Towels. I mean...it has a spray bottle, after all. I have to emphasize that this was not ANYWHERE near as messy as I assumed. The spray should go on the mitt and then on your body. Not hard. Unless your challenged like me and accidentally spray the toilet...haha.. :)
- Rubs off a little bit on clothes and sheets before you shower it off...just like a spray tan would.
So, feel free to take my tanning .02 or leave it.... These are what have worked for me and my fair skin. I've used MANY self tanning products, but these are just some of my thoughts on recent products. Be sure to read the web reviews, too, just so you get other opinions. I don't know about you, but I barely read product info anymore. I just read reviews before I purchase things like this... *shrugs*
Yeah.. I just wrote a super long post about tanners. Wow. Eh well... Happy Friday, friends! :)



7 comments:
Ahhh thanks for the advice! I need to try that fake bake flawless! I use tan towels a lot, but not as often as I want to because of the price. Happy weekend!
Xo,
Katie
sappyandhappy.blogspot.com
Thanks so much for posting these reviews. I have a bridal shower this weekend and want a little color. I will definitely have to try one of these!!
You know about me and my skin cancer so I'm a spray tan queen now!! I'm definitely gonna try the fake bake flawless in between sprays though!! Thanks for doing this!!
I am SO glad you posted this! I am all about NOT going to the tanning bed! I use to go ALL the time when I was younger and now I'm finding these tans in a bottle!
Have you ever used the Banana Boat sunless tanners? I learned about it from a pageant friend and have had great luck with it. I tend to use the Med to Dark b/c I like my color to be noticeable.
http://www.walmart.com/ip/10448308?wmlspartner=wlpa&adid=22222222227000000000&wl0=&wl1=g&wl2=&wl3=21486607510&wl4=&wl5=pla&veh=sem
Fake and Bake is the best! My sister got it for me a few months ago and I finally tired it. Seriously the best product out there and super easy to apply. Tan Towels are my second pick.
This is a great post! I love learning about new self tanners! I've used the tan towels before - they are get for packing for vacay too!
Post a Comment